‍

MSP Direct Mail That Gets Opened: Using Personalized Cyber Score Cards

Getting prospects to open, let alone respond to, your MSP's direct mail can feel like an uphill battle. In a world saturated with digital noise and generic marketing, how do you make your physical mailer cut through and capture attention? Standard tactics often fall flat. This post explores a practical, effective strategy using a personalized, printed Cyber Score Card as a tangible, attention-grabbing element in your direct mail campaigns. We'll dive into the unique approach of including prospect employee photos (sourced ethically and transparently) to create a powerful "juicy hook" that not only gets your mail opened but starts meaningful conversations.

The MSP Direct Mail Dilemma: Cutting Through the Clutter

You invest time and resources into crafting direct mail campaigns, whether it's introductory letters or creative mailers using hooks like asprin packs or casino chips. Yet, too often, these efforts end up unopened in the recycling bin. The core challenge is providing immediate, tangible value that overcomes recipient skepticism and inertia. Generic flyers about your services rarely achieve this. You need something relevant and intriguing enough to make them pause and engage.

A Powerful Tool: The Personalized Cyber Score Card Approach

Instead of just telling prospects about cybersecurity risks, show them something relevant to their specific organization. The tactic involves generating a concise, visually engaging Cyber Score Card for each prospect and including it as a physical printout in your direct mail envelope. This scorecard provides a snapshot related to their potential cyber exposure, shifting the dynamic from a sales pitch to providing valuable (and intriguing) information upfront.

Step-by-Step: Preparing Your Score Card for Mailing

Executing this tactic effectively involves a few key preparation steps:

Generation and Branding

First, you need to generate the Score Cards. Tools like the Iceberg Cyber App allow you to set up a campaign and simply load the domain names of your target prospects. The system then generates an individual Score Card for each. Crucially, ensure the output is configured with your MSP's branding – logo, colors, and contact information – for a professional look that represents your business well.

Printing for Impact

Presentation matters. Print the Score Cards on thick paper stock. This gives the scorecards "heft", making them feel more substantial and less like a disposable flyer. Pay attention to printer settings, especially for double-sided designs with colored elements. We recommends using the "Flip on the long edge" setting to ensure proper alignment and avoid unprofessional bleed-through.

Folding and Inclusion

Once printed, neatly trifold the scorecard. Then, simply insert it into the envelope along with your primary mailer. This tactic isn't meant to replace your existing successful playbooks but to amplify them by adding another layer of value and intrigue.

The Game Changer: Hyper-Personalization with Employee Photos

What elevates this tactic from interesting to compelling is the potential inclusion of actual employee photos from the prospect's company on the Score Card. This hyper-personalization is the core of the "juicy hook."

How It Works

It's vital to understand how these photos are obtained ethically and transparently. The process involves:

1. Performing a dark web breach check associated with the prospect's domain to identify potentially compromised employee email addresses.
2. Checking if those employees have linked their LinkedIn profile to their company's official LinkedIn page.
3. Verifying if their LinkedIn profile picture is set to publicly viewable.

If all these conditions are met, the publicly available photo can be included on the Score Card. This uses readily accessible public information to create a powerful point of relevance.

Why It Grabs Attention

Seeing familiar faces, or at least faces of colleagues associated with their company, on a security-related document instantly makes it nice and personal. It cuts through the impersonal nature of typical mail and makes the recipient pay attention. It transforms the scorecard from generic data into something directly connected to the people within their organization.

More Than a Hook

While getting the mail opened is the first hurdle, the Score Card's real value lies in the conversations it enables. This isn't about fear-mongering; it's about creating a legitimate reason to connect and offer genuine help. The focus should be purely on education and assistance:

• "We noticed your email might have appeared on a breach list..."
• "To help improve your cyber hygiene, we strongly recommend you change your passwords regularly."
• "Have you considered using a password manager to create and store strong, unique passwords?"
• "Let's also discuss implementing Multi Factor Authentication (MFA) for better account security."

By leading with education and actionable advice, you build trust and position your MSP as a helpful expert, not just another vendor. The Score Card serves as a lead magnet for these valuable, trust-building interactions.

Amplifying Your Existing Playbook

Think of the personalized Cyber Score Card as an amplifier for your current direct mail efforts. It’s another piece of valuable, tangible information you provide prospects, increasing the odds they'll open the envelope and potentially reply. Integrate it into your proven processes to add a powerful layer of personalization and relevance.

Getting your MSP's direct mail noticed requires more than just a clever gimmick; it requires delivering immediate, personalized value. Incorporating a printed, personalized Cyber Score Card provides that compelling reason for prospects to engage. It acts as a powerful hook to get your mail opened and, more importantly, serves as a springboard for meaningful, educational conversations about improving cyber hygiene. Consider adding this tactic to your playbook to amplify your outreach and build trust from the first touch point.